Aldo - final score: 9/40

AldoAddress: 309 Oxford Street

Map: Click here to find this store.

Score last season: 10

Verdict: More lows than highs. Aldo provides a dreadful example of how not to merchandise footwear.

Looks - 2

A belting version of the Balenciaga Lego shoe is the only thing cheering up this dismal range. A multitude of sickly sweet pastel patent peep toes water down any credibility on women's styles.

Meanwhile, men get a bizarre mix of North American casual mules, recycled Prada styles from the 1990s and dreadful washed leather loafers more suited to the obsure indies in London's grittier districts.

Mix - 2

Merchandising is nonsensical. Aldo picks a construction and repeats it in as many colours as possible for women. Men get random casuals directly adjacent to formals. It appears to be largely driven by colour story – a white moulded sole casual style sits against a good pale grey brogue-detail trainer.

Store - 3

Most of the footwear here is like the music playing in the background – from the 1980s. Shelving runs around the side of the unit from the floor to head height. There are far too many shoes on each shelf, making it even harder to decipher fashion stories amid poor merchandising.

Staff, however, are very attentive.

Value - 2

Aldo has introduced a premium line called Aldo Collection. For women the range features patent peep toes similar in design to Aldo's mainline. However, the price difference is vast – £175 versus £60 – without justification.

Separately, straw wedges are above the competition at £60. Tattoo detail boots for men are good value at £80 but old-fashioned loafers are dated and pricey at £85.

Vox pop: Tasha Mackintyre, 29, nursery nurse

Tasha-Mackintyre-Aldo• Are you a regular shopper here?
No, I can never get the size I need.  Also, I like kitten heels and they tend to only have high heels.

• What does this shop mean to you?
Everything is always really high, but I still check it out.

• How impressed are you with this season's offerings?
I did like the styles this season, but there was just nothing for me.  

• What is it they're doing well?
I love the colours, especially this season.

• What have they missed out that you would have liked to have seen?
I would love to see more kitten heels. Tall people don't always want to be taller, and flats are so unsexy.