River Island - final score: 35/40

River-IslandAddress: 301 Oxford Street

Map: Click here to find this store.

Score last season: 28

Verdict: Value has been added via design and mega merchandising. Footwear is no
afterthought here.

Looks - 9

Everything here is a statement, from metallic gladiator sandals on a wooden construction to covered platform peep toes, stone-coloured peep-toe ankle boots, black and gold double-layer platforms, grey snake and patent shoe boots, jelly shoes and Hessian-heeled tribal wedges.

Men get rainbow-bright high tops, side-laced canvas pumps, purple and grey suede boots alongside pointed last formals.

Mix - 8

Fashion dominates the women's offer with just a sprinkling of seasonal essentials such as ballerinas and a version of the Ugg. Sexy ultra-high heels are the order of the day and each shoe far exceeds its price tag for design content.

The men's offer is 60/40 casual to formal. There is a wall and a freestanding unit of cheaper hanging product, while formals are displayed more traditionally on shelves.

Store - 9

There is a clever use of props such as a hanging punch bag which is covered in belts and shoes hanging by their laces, and turf-topped display tables which intersperse footwear with footballs in the men's department.

The women's department is well lit and the use of embossed black wallpaper gives a luxurious boutique feel. Footwear is prominently displayed in the windows and merchandised within clothing around the store.

Value - 9

River Island beats Topshop hands down on value, purely because there is added value in every one of its lines. A distressed metallic gladiator chunky wooden platform is just £40 while a strappy pink peep toe shoe with sculpted heel is just £55. Double-layered cut-in platforms are £70.

A men's purple canvas and grey suede ankle boot has a neon sole and is £27. A clear message to the competition: must try harder.

Vox pop: Olivia Gibson, 21, teacher

Olivia-Gibson-River-Island• Are you a regular shopper here?
I used to be when I went to uni because it was close by. Now, I come once month.

• What does this shop mean to you?
I come for particular things. The trousers fit me really well.

• How impressed are you with this season's offerings?
I liked the more country feel and the florals.  

• What is it they're doing well?
Variety. They have almost every style.

• What have they missed out that you would have liked to have seen?
They could have better flat shoes.